The Promise Pathways initiative is one of LBCC’s student success strategies and its signature effort in support of the Long Beach College Promise partnership with Long Beach Unified School District (LBUSD) and California State University, Long Beach (CSULB). LBCC implemented several innovations including an evidence-based, multiple measures placement and prescriptive first-semester success plans with registration priority for Promise Pathways students. Students were placed in English and math courses based broadly on their high school achievement (e.g., HS GPA, last grade in discipline) rather than traditional standardized tests.
The Promise Pathways launched in the fall of 2012 with 933 students from LBUSD and significantly expanded in the fall of 2013 to include two additional districts (Bellflower Unified and Paramount Unified School Districts) and reaching 1325 students. In the fall of 2014, expanded further to include two additional districts (ABC and Los Alamitos Unified School Districts) and a private high school in Long Beach (Saint Joseph High School) with an anticipated cohort of more than 1500 students.
Promise Pathways students benefit from several innovations including alternative placement and first-semester success plans with registration priority. Participating students are placed in English and math courses based broadly on their high school achievement (e.g., HS GPA, last course and grade in discipline) rather than traditional standardized tests. Pathways students are also required to enroll full-time and to complete key foundational courses beginning in their first semester.
Achievement of Early Educational Milestones
The Promise Pathways substantially increased the number and percentage of students who completed key early educational milestones in their first two years, including successful completion of transfer-level English and math and the achievement of behavioral intent to transfer (successful completion of 12 transfer level units and attempting transfer-level English or math). In fact, Promise Pathways students’ rates of successful completion of these milestones approach and even substantially exceed those typically achieved by students at LBCC in six years.
F2012 Promise Pathways achievement in first two years vs. F2011 LBUSD and six-year achievement rate for F2008 six-year cohort from LBUSD
The Effects of Multiple Measures Assessment on Placement
Over the past few years, less than 15% of first-time LBCC students have assessed into transfer-level English while less than 10% of students have assessed into transfer-level Math. In the past, this has been taken as prima facie evidence of students' lack of readiness for college. However, starting in 2011, LBCC began a program of research to test college readiness more directly by working to determine the best predictors of performance in college ready courses.
This research found that student performance on standardized tests were only weak predictors of performance in college courses and that by far the best predictors of student performance in college level courses was their performance in high school courses, including most strongly their consistent performance on a wide variety of assessment methods across multiple disciplines, instructors, and years (also known as high school GPA) as well as their last course and grade in the same discipline.
From that research, Long Beach City College developed a multiple measures assessment algorithm weighting students' high school achievement and standardized assessment in proportion to their utility in predicting student performance. Assessment into transfer-level English increased from not quite 15% using traditional standardized assessment in the previous cohort to almost 60% using the evidence-based, multiple measures assessment. In math, assessment into transfer-level math increased from less than 10% to over 30%.
Percentage of students assessed into transfer-level English and Math by cohort
Importantly, despite dramatically expanding placement directly into college-level coursework, students succeeded in those courses at rates that were no different than students who had received multiple semesters of developmental instruction and had persisted through multiple years at the college (both typically strong predictors of higher rates of success), providing powerful validation of the multiple measures placement method.
Success rates in transfer-level English and Math courses in Fall 2012
Equity Effects of the Promise Pathways
As a result, access to and entry into transfer-level courses increased for all demographic groups. Rates of achievement of these milestones increased for every demographic group, with some of the largest relative gains made by Latino and African American students. In fact, in every case but one, the rates of achievement of these milestones by students of color in the Promise Pathways in 2012 matched and often significantly outpaced those of the highest achieving group in 2011 (indicated by the blue lines in each figures).
Achievement of educational milestones in first two years for
F2011 LBUSD students by ethnicity
Achievement of educational milestones in first two years for
F2012 Promise Pathways students by ethnicity
Recognition for the Promise Pathways
From the very beginning, the effort that the college has collectively put into the Promise Pathways program has received recognition and acclaim throughout the state and nationally. As that effort has begun to bear fruit in the significant achievements summarized above, the college has been recognized with several awards including:
In addition, numerous colleges and organizations have begun to explore the potential of the Promise Pathways and the Long Beach College Promise as potential state and national models for how to meaningfully improve student outcomes amidst the many difficulties faced by today's community colleges, either inviting the college to share its results or coming to visit the college, including:
- Invited Panelist, White House College Opportunity Working Session, August 12, 2014
- Invited Testimony, United States Senate, Committee on Health, Education, Labor, & Pension Hearing: Strengthening Minority Serving Institutions: Best Practices and Innovations for Student Success, May 13, 2014
- Visit of full California State Senate Delegation, March 6, 2013
- Invited Speaker, Little Hoover Commission, October 23, 2012
Promise Pathways students also give the program very positive reviews. Pathways Students’ overall satisfaction level with the program is high, their general consensus was that the program improved from the first to the second semester, and they cite priority registration, First Semester Success Plans, and alternative assessment as the features which helped them the most.
In addition, LBCC continues to implement and experiment with several other pilot efforts to support Promise Pathways students. These include:
- Achievement Coaches
- Contextualized Reading
- College Success and Career Exploration Courses
2012 Introductory Video
Additional Resources for Colleges and Organizations
From the very beginning, Long Beach City College has worked very hard to be both transparent about the results of the Promise Pathways and open in sharing the methods that we have used. As early as late 2011, the college built a suite of tools that it freely released that would allow any California Community College to replicate its research and explore multiple measures assessment at its colleges. Collaborating with the RP Group and the California Community Colleges Chancellor's Office, this suite was further refined and additional support was given to any college that sought to perform the research themselves as part of the Student Transcript Enhanced Placement Study (STEPS). These tools remain available for any community college or four-year college to use and adapt to improve placement at their college under an Attribution-NonCommercial Creative Commons License. This effort eventually formed the core of what is now Multiple Measures Assessment Project, which is building a statewide multiple measures data warehouse and placement tool for the entire California Community College system.
LBCC will continue to evaluate and improve the effort and provide assistance to other colleges in their hopes to do the same. Copies of various internal reports and presentations are available for review in the column on the right.
Additional resources for institutions working to develop local programs similar to the Promise Pathways or the Long Beach College Promise can be found here.
If you have any general questions about the Promise Pathways or the Long Beach College Promise or about arranging additional opportunities to discuss the programs in greater detail, please direct questions to Alicia Kruizenga, Director of School Relations and International Education at firstname.lastname@example.org or (562) 938-4083.
Research, results, and future updates
If you have any questions about the research conducted for or about the Promise Pathways or any suggestions for this site, please direct questions to John Hetts, Director of Institutional Research at email@example.com or 562-938-4052. If you would like to receive future updates about the results of the program, you can do so via email here.